My family (husband and two kids 16 yrs and 13 yrs) visited Put In Bay on 06/14/12. We went to Tony's Garage for lunch and was so happy we did! Great food and fun atmosphere. The "garage" has big roll up doors and the breeze was blowing and it was a perfect day (well, us Florida natives were a bit chilly but at least we weren't burning up hot!)
We tried almost everything on the menu! The kids had the BBQ sandwich and both loved it. We sampled the boneless wings...not bad. But the highlight (for me anyway) was the Garage Burger! OMG...what a burger! And yes, I ate the whole thing!
I totally recommend this fun little restaurant in you're at Put In Bay. I'm not sure how crazy it gets towards evening (there is a bar) but at lunch it was perfect for our fun seeking family!
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.