I reviewed Gino's about two years ago and I wasn't kind because of the number of pizza's we had purchased that were not prepared as ordered. At that time I threatened to find a new Pizzeria which I did for two years. On our way home from spending the day on Put-In-Bay we decided to give Gino's another try and called in an order from the road. Nothing special but simply 3 of their standard Pizzas (1 Pepperoni, 1 Ultimate Veggy and 1 Taco Pizza). Wouldn't you know but two of the three were wrong. The Pepperoni had no pepperoni and the Taco was missing the olives and tomatoes. I like the flavor of Gino's pizza but don't understand why they can't be prepared as ordered. It's back to Marcos for this family.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.