We visited twice during a three day stay.
First experience: arrived just as they opened for the day. Food was good and service friendly but SLOW. To be fair I'm sure the kitchen was just getting up and running for the day. Food was of fine, "BW3's" type quality pub and bare fare. We left happy but not overwhelmed with "Wow"
Second experience: Sunday evening around 7:00 p.m. Food good, service still excellent and very quick. You are paying for the experience. More fantastic live music and the location seated on a patio with the lake view and breezes was fantastic.
Overall the food is good. Foodies need not apply but if you want tasty, perfectly great food then you should certainly be able to find something you'll enjoy on this menu.
Live music offered is very talented.
Firehouse itself (you enter via this building) and outdoor atmosphere an obvious win.