We've been back a dozen times with family and friends and have never been disappointed. We save it for special occasions - anniversary, Lobster Festival (three lobsters for $50!) and their fall mushroom festival (puffball soup) all interesting, unpretentious and in a cosy setting (we always try to reserve the back window corner). Someone tried to burn them down last week. Criminal fire at 5 a.m., could have killed good, hard-working, honest people who try hard and give value for dollar.
If you want pretentious, stay away. If you want to be coddled by people who care, give it a try.