I normally have no problem with Caffrey's but not today. I ordered the Surf and Turf like I have many times before but today it came covered in mushrooms. I told the waitress I wasn't going to eat it so she offered to replace the steak without mushrooms. I said that would be great so I sat and ate my salad and waited for a new steak. While I was eating another waitress showed up and told me I didn't order the surf and turf because that wasn't available till 4 what I did order was a steak sandwich with shrimp added that always has mushrooms. I told her that when I order something I should always get the same thing and that it was confusing that I would get something different depending on what time of day I order it. She left me to eat my salad and a third woman came to my table to explain to me how the menu worked. I told her that I had ordered the same thing many times and never had a problem. She continued to explain the way the specials work but at this point I had enough and told her to leave me alone and cancel my steak because I was leaving. She said that was fine with her. As we left our first waitress was apologizing for the mix up and said it was all her fault. I said it wasn't a big deal until the third woman came to my table and lectured me about the menu. She told me that the woman who upset me was the owner. I don't know if I will be back to Caffrey's anytime soon.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.