With all of the other great reviews, I almost feel guilty for not chiming in. So first, the positives.
Yes, service is excellent, atmosphere is nice, prices are reasonable, wine list is excellent, and yes, the place is pretty busy so reservations are recommended.
Now then, the pizza - very good, fresh ingredients, love the thinner crust. Still, as a pizza hound, I've had better, sorry, I just have. Especially left over - this one was a lot better fresh, but didn't stand up well to the left over test, and I love leftover pizza.
Will we go back? Absolutely. With all the good things going, I have to try a regular meal, like lasagna or something like that. Then, I'll come back and review again, hopefully join the rest of the crowd with an over the top positive experience to relate. : )