When we arrived on the island we saw kids advertising for Domino's, so it was nice to know that we could find a tasty local alternative. Being Saturday night, though, the wait for delivery was very long, so we placed our order for pickup. Our wait was still an hour, and when we arrived it wasn't ready. The shack itself was like a sauna. One thing that they didn't tell us over the phone was that they only accept cash.
Most importantly though, the pizza was good. It had a thinner crust and tasty sauce. I would definitely recommend Pizza Shack, and have every intention of ordering from them again if we're fortunate enough to return to Oak Island. Just make sure you plan ahead for delivery and have cash on hand.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.