We tried these guys out this past weekend while in Nags Head. I saw them online and they were recommended by our hotel. It wasn't hard to get a table on a Saturday night but we did go right before the season started (weekend before Memorial Day). My fiancee ordered the $35 special (salad, choice of two entrees/sides, and then a dessert). He ordered the crab stuffed flounder and rice. I ordered the broiled shrimp and scallops.
Everything looked great and came out rather quickly. We also received some corn bread which was pretty delicious. The only complaint my fiancee had was the rice he received with his flounder tasted like it had been sitting for too long so it didn't taste fresh. He thought the stuffed flounder was GREAT though.
The only complaint I had with my meal was the shrimp I received were a bit tasteless and overdone. The scallops, however, WERE DIVINE. Cooked PERFECTLY, extremely tender, and they are HUGE this season for some reason.
We shared the dessert that came with the special which was a double fudge brownie. The only complaint we had about the brownie was the fruit sauce they had on top. It may be great to others but it just wasn't our thing. It didn't stop us from enjoying the warm brownie, however.
Now, the real reason as to why I'm using the average rating... for 2 people, our bill already included an 18% gratuity. 18% gratuity for just two people. I'm not from OBX so this was rather odd to me. I'm also a voluntarily, FABULOUS over tipper because I've worked in the food service industry whether it's serving, hosting, or selling. I also know that in most cases, you're going to have a gratuity already included in parties of at least 6-8 or more. I was taken aback by this mandatory charge for just 2 people and want to let others know in advance that it's their policy. I didn't encounter another local restaurant in OBX that had this policy. I'm not saying our service wasn't great but I was rather thrown off by this policy. I have never been to a restaurant in my life that includes an 18% gratuity for any less than 6 people.