We were in Cashiers for a week and found almost all restaurants closed for the Season. We stumbled in and found the pizza choices to be extensive and much to our surprise, some excellent choices for wine.
We ordered a custom pizza and can honestly say that it was one of the best pizza I've ever had.
The service has to be worked out as one orders at the counter and (it seemed) you had to go back to the counter if you wanted anything else. I think my rating would have been higher if they had a better organized table service. In any case, this place was a life saver as it was either pizza or some fast food joint for that night.