Good service, tropical settings. Great jambalaya and great dessert. The coffee was nice and strong. Friendly service.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.
311 - 315 of 536 reviews
My Favorite Restaurant On Hatteras Island. I'd Rather Pay A Little More & Get Really Good Food. Fried Shrimp Is Best I've Had Anywhere. The Sauce On The Beef Medallions Was Very Good.
We were a group of 12 from Ohio and New York and had a very delightful time at Rusty's. I had read a few poor reviews and although everyone is entitled to their opinion, they are very, very wrong. Our group ordered several seafood items and were very pleased. The service was friendly and efficient. Rusty, thank you for a wonderful dining experience.
We ate at two restaurants while on vacation, and this was my favorite. The homemade desserts are to DIE for!
that is not meant to be a disparging remark. But anyone that has visited here knows that fine dining is not why you come to Hatteras. Now with that being said, the food here is well prepared and fresh. The chef, yes chef, not cook, knows what he is doing in the kitchen.
If you are looking for a good meal anywhere on the island then this place is a recommended try.