Fanaka Lodge deserves 4-5* for a 1 night stay. Overall good service in a convenient location. (The stay was included in our 4 day mid-range Safari tour in June 2019). Staff were friendly and helpful.
Room: Our room with two beds was basic but very clean and comfortable. Mosquito nets and portable fan provided. The en suite bathroom had a strong hot shower. Unfortunately, we didn't have time to use the swimming pool but it looked clean.
Food: 3 course dinner options were selected from a varied menu and included: soup of the day, fish or meat served with fries/rice/salad, and fruit for dessert. Nice tasty food - but not amazing. (During high season, I think they serve a buffet dinner and have live music). Breakfast was British style with bacon, eggs, toast, pancake and fruit + tea/coffee/juice. A good tasty start for safari and a decent packed lunch box.
Location: We stayed here on the 1st night of safari, straight after visiting Manyara National Park (<10mins). Also convenient for visiting Ngorongoro (~1hr) or Serengeti.
Wifi: Main downside was that I couldn't connect to the Wifi from my room. However, I did have cell service on AirTel so it wasn't a big issue.
Overall, Fanaka Lodge represents a clean and comfortable stay for 1 night at a convenient location for budget or lower mid-range travelers. But the Fanaka experience is definitely less memorable when compared to subsequent nights of our safari where we stayed in a tented camp inside the Serengeti or on the edge of the Ngorongoro crater. So shop around to see if this is really the best option for your safari!