We went for an early Friday night dinner with another couple.
The location is really nice, being right on the Black River. It's unfortunate that there aren't more windows or outdoor seating.
All of the food was very good. My wife and I both had burgers, and we were very happy with them. But, the best part of the meal was the fries...they were some of the best fries anywhere. It's unfortunate that they call them 'cheese fries'. 'Cheese fries' have real melted cheese on them...at Maggies you get their excellent fries with a disappointing cup of orange nacho cheez-food product.
They have a very good selection of beers for a restaurant in Watertown...probably 30 drafts. Unfortunately, it seemed that the cooler was having issues since the beer wasn't really as cold as it should have been.
For seating, I'd recommend avoiding the main room on the first floor. There's a skee-ball game and a couple of basketball games in there. Once someone started playing those, conversation became difficult.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.