We often frequent Little Red as constancy without surprises are key. Their salads are wonderful as are the steamed mussels. Try the crisp calamari salad with mixed greens or Frisee Aux Lardons with bacon, shallots and a poached egg. I for one, LOVE their burgers, cooked to perfection just as you order. Oh, and the frittes (frys) are done as one might expect in Brussels or Antwerp.
This is a neighborhood place and relies heavily on locals and repeat business year round. You know the food is going to be good. Is it cheap, hey, nothing in the Hamptons is cheap. But the food at Little Red is well worth it's tag.