We had visitors from abroad and within a 2 weeks span we visited many eateries on Long Island, to give them a taste of every-day life. We had no disappointments but for the Millenium Diner. It should have been a simple breakfast, which diners like this do pretty well. The potatoes were burned charcoal black and the toast was so cold the butter just sat there. We showed the potatoes to the maitresse-d' who simply said they would get us new potatoes. When the new potatoes arrived, the eggs were cold and to our chagrin, the potatoes were still charcoal black, only this time they flipped them upside down so that we couldn't see it at first glance.
I have been to this diner several times before and should have known better.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.