Went on the third say it was open this season. SOOOOOO disappointed. Not the same as last year at all... I discovered they are under new ownership, and do I have a few choice words for this new owner.
I'll start with the positives. The buffalo wings are still good; but really, it's difficult to screw them up. The atmosphere is a little nicer; the paint, wood floors refinished, outdoor eating is updated. The service and employees were nice... to my face....
Which brings me to the negative. The employees were deceiving! The chef and the owner took out the pizza I had ordered. I got there early so I was watching them. I saw them examining it so I assumed the chef was teaching the owner something, or vice versa. They gave me the pizza box and wings, smiled, and I left. I came home, we opened the box, TERRIBLE. The UGLIEST pizza I have ever seen. There were holes the size of quarters, and an 8" cut/slice. To make it worse, not only did they give me an awful pizza, they knew they did, and tried to cover it up with MORE CHEESE. However, the cheese was too fresh on the pizza and still white; clearly they tried to cover their mistake. The appearance was so bad, it turned me off from trying it. I eventually did and it was ok. But they are sneaky! $4.00 for extra cheese and the total cheese on it was not even that of a regular pizza, nevermind EXTRA. Rip Off!!
Overall, the new owners have a thing, or 12, to learn about pleasing their customers enough to have them return. I live 2 streets from Nick's and will not go again in 2011.
AWFUL! Sneaky, deceitful, deceptive, overpriced, and just not what it used to be. Don't even bother this year.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.