This hotel truly made my visit to Shelter Island perfect. The rooms were beautiful, and the house truly felt like a home. The pool was gorgeous and perfect for relaxing.
The food was absolutely delicious, be it for brunch or dinner. I strongly recommend the octopus, as well as the tempura avocado. The poolside bar and indoor bar each created great atmospheres to hang out on a summer night.
The staff truly made you feel pampered, whether it was waiters and waitresses in the restaurant, bartenders outside or inside, or Suzanne, who was everywhere. They truly care about making your experience the best it can be.
I would absolutely recommend staying here, and know I will again in the future.More