I had been at Witherbee's in June and had a good meal. I recently returned with a party of six and was underwhelmed with the service. Prices are reasonable and there is a good selection of menu items. Our waitress seemed distracted, yet the restaurant was not fill. We had to go to the next table to get the missing silverware, and had to hunt her down to return a very undercooked burger that the kitchen did return to us cooked properly. It has been ordered medium and was cold to the touch and bright red in the interior. The lobster that one of us had was excellent. When a restaurant is busy one is very understanding of delays, but when the place was less than 3/4 full we should have had better attention.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.