I was staying in New Paltz and on my last morning decided to try this bakery for the rave reviews about the lemon cakes. We love lemon poppy anything. When I arrived I decided to have a breakfast sandwich on a roll. Loved it and the roll and never before had mustard on an egg breakfast sandwich. Glad I did. I bought 2 small lemon poppy, I believe called bites. They did have a glaze on it and asked if I called ahead would he bake a cake without it. The website does say they do made to order. I was told NO. And I would find this not very sweet. Not very sweet is indeed subjective and I won't complain about that. I was just put off by what appeared to be his "I'm the artist " attitude. Breakfast sandwich, 5 stars. attitude 1 star and lemon bites 3 stars.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.