My husband & I ate here before & it was nice, so when we returned to Rochester we planned another visit. I will not be returning again.
It was only when we were half way through our meal & another couple who were seated next to us, did we realise what the specials were. Our waitress failed to even mention specials, to us. We ordered & shared a artisan 'cheese sticks'. The cheese was not melted or even soft in the middle . They were incredibly salty as was our whole meal.
I had the 'Jail Island Salmon'. It had very little flavour except for the SALT that smothered the whole plate. It was so overseasoned. The lobster tail was tiny, overcooked & rubbery.
My husband wanted his steak 'filet mignon' medium, but it too was overcooked & was medium well. The desert I had was a meringue nest, it was ok, nothing special.
I was soooo disappointed in our return to this establisment. I will never go back again.
Just to add that our waitress was overly attentive. She refilled our water glasses eleven times throught out the meal. Continuing to refill them even after we had asked here to leave them & telling her that we would fill them ourselves. We were also serenaged with ' Yourrrr Welccooommmmeeee' 38 times, throughout our meal which only lasted an hour & a half.
It has since become a running joke with my husband & I and we now draw it out to four seconds (just like our waitress did). It is easily the most memorable thing about our whole experience here.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.