This is a very charming place, easily accessible and with easy parking. However, with the wide variety of quality restaurants in the Rhinebeck area, it is unfortunate that Albany Post Roadhouse doesn't recognize that in order to compete in this market they need more than a quaint atmosphere. They had better offer good service and quality food. To begin with our waitress (very pleasant but clearly not on the ball this particular evening) forgot to process our appetizer order. Next only 5 of the 6 meals ordered were delivered to the table. After several minutes when the final meal had not arrived, we had to remind her that we were one short. So in total 6 meals were ordered. 2 of the meals were the evening fish special, both served barely lukewarm and with a different side than the waitress said, 3 burgers (2 delivered with cold, soggy fries) and the last meal was the Italian salad with crab cake ordered as an entree. When finally delivered to the table it was the wrong salad. The waitress told me she was sure I had ordered salad with blue cheese. Since I never eat blue cheese I knew that was not possible. When the correct salad finally came, it was about the size of a typical side salad. It certainly didn't present as an entree. The crab cake, slightly larger in size than a silver dollar, was predominantly "filler". The cartilage and shells didn't enhance the experience. So of the 6 meals ordered, only one was correct and served at the right temperature. I am the first to admit that every restaurant can have an "off night", but do problems with 5 out of 6 meals constitute just an "off night"?