What's not to love about a moderately priced Mario Batali restaurant that actually cares about the food it serves? Mario's food is basic, often rustic, but done with the freshest of ingredients, made to order for the most part, and it doesn't disappoint. Tarry Lodge has a hodgepodge of rooms- but no matter. You come for the food, not the surroundings. But definitely, always, get a reservation. It is difficult to get in, even on a weekday night, without one. They are always busy. Once you try the food, you will know why.