Billy's is located on the main street in Old Forge, it's easy to get to and since it sits in the parking lot they offer plenty of off street parking.
I completely recommend reservations. It's an intimate space and with the good food that is prepared it fills up quick.
There were four of us for dinner at 6:30 on a Friday night. We had reservations and the owner, Billy, greeted us and we were seated right away.
The server, Adrian was very attentive. She was friendly and quick to acknowledge us and get our drink order. We didn't have any appetizers. The portions are generous.
We never felt rushed which is nice since after a long week of work we like to relax when dining out.
In some of the reviews I have read people have commented on the salad dressing. They have a house balsamic vinaigrette that is on the table and they have a ranch, but you have to ask for that. I had the house and did not find it too vinegary, but I did add a little sprinkle of salt, pepper and some cheese to jazz it up a bit, but that is how I like my dressings. When I asked my friends what they thought they said it was fine.
I ordered The House Specialty Entree Chicken and Scallop dijonaise. WOW!!! I loved it. Created to perfection I recommend it highly. In fact I'd like to go back to Old Forge soon because I've been wishing for it. My friends had, Chicken Marsala, Bowl of Pasta with a meat ball, and Shrimp Scampi. Everyone enjoyed their meal and dining experience.
Give Billy's a try while in Old Forge you really won't regret it.