After reading reviews, I made a special effort to find the gallery. I, too, was disappointed - not by the quality, but by the meager offerings. After reading the response to another disappointed visiter, I understand why - I was there close to mid-October. However, Oia was crowded with tourists that day with more than 1cruise ship in the harbor. I plan on returning to Oia next October. I don't know if I'll make the effort to find the shop again or not.