We returned to Barnaby's, a place with great memories for us, after many years absence from the area. Read some mixed reviews and heard from a local that it just wasn't as good as we remembered, but decided to check it out for ourselves and we're glad. Although one member of our party of four wasn't thrilled with his food, the rest of us, who all ordered steak, were completely satisfied and thought it was wonderful. The appetizers, Calamari and Baked Stuffed Littleneck Clams were both tasty. All of our salads were very fresh and the house made dressings were all super good. The steaks were perfectly cooked and flavorful. My favorite side was the oven roasted red potatoes over the mashed or baked versions which were unremarkable. as I mentioned there was the one issue which was the Salmon and Risotto dinner. Undercooked risotto that was definitely not right, although the rest of it was okay. After we all tried it and agreed We mentioned to the server and she was truly surprised and apologetic. We were treated to complimentary dessert which we did appreciate. Overall we enjoyed the experience and felt the restaurant still lived up to our expectations.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.