I will preface this review by saying I have never been to New Paltz before. Found the restaurant using a google search and decided to try it since it had its own brewery. Ordered one of their homemade beers and the BrewMaster Burger for dinner. The beer was very good. The burger was very large and was very good. I added the mushrooms, onions and bacon for an extra $2. The brew city fries are my favorite and didn't let me down. Ordered the PB Cup Pie for desert which was also very good. I left the place full and satisfied. The total bill for 2 dinners, 2 drinks and 2 deserts came to $45. Not bad for a very last minute choice. They also offer outdoor seating but we sat inside due to the weather. If I am ever back in the area would return to the Gilded Otter.