I have been to dinner and the bar here, which are both great. I thought the hotel would be of the same quality, but I was wrong. I knew that some inn's and motel's in montauk are no frills, but this was a bit extreme. I paid for a room with a shower and two beds. I didn't want to touch anything in the room once I walked in. The bed was gross, with a mattress from the 50s. The shower worked, but had no curtain. the towels were washed, but still had many brown stains on them. I ended up leaving before it got dark and paying 4x more for the last hotel room I could find in montauk. I didnt feel like it would be safe to spend the night.
If you wish to stay here, ask to see the room first then make your decision.