Although this place is pricey, you at least feel like your money is well spent, as the portions are huge. We ordered a swordfish special which was out of this world and a fusilli with scallops and mushrooms dish that I kept waiting for the taste to hit my tongue, but alas, never did. Also try the garlic fries - they are amazing. We actually ended up spending the least amount of money here than we did at any of the other restaurants in and around the area, even though this is supposedly the crown jewel of Montauk. No complaints here about that. Just don't expect amazing service here, or anywhere in Montauk for that matter. You are a captive audience there, and most restaurateurs and shop-owners know it.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.