We jumped on the chance to stay at the Manor in February due to its cheapest rates of the year since it was the offseason. We arrived several hours before check-in but were able to get into our room around noon, which was a nice surprise. The front desk said its not the norm., but it helped that we booked a suite beforehand (I assume several rooms were available and/or not in use).
The lobby of the Manor was beautiful, a real warm feeling to it with plenty of charm. Things changed abruptly as we entered the hallway to our room. The hallways are drab and dim and my hope was our room would not be the same. We were ecstatic upon entering our suite (room 213). It was very nicely decorated and clean and had one the the biggest balconies at Montauk Manor. Since each room is owned by someone different, its sort of luck of the draw to what style and decor is hidden behind any door, so I can see how some reviewers here can post something negative about a room, if they happened to get a lousy, unkept room. In a way, its sort of a crapshoot. I would assume the suites (more expensive) have a better chance of being nicer overall rooms, but that's just a guess.
Based on the room map at the Manor, many rooms on the 2nd and 3rd floors have balconies of some sort, while rooms on levels 1 and 4 offered few, if any.
I checked out the indoor pool/fitness area and both looked nice. The grounds of the Manor were well kept as well, I can imagine in the summer them being very appealing with the outdoor pool and tennis courts.
There is a restaurant accessible through the lobby. Instead of heading down there, we ordered "room service" from it, which ended up being more like "take-out" as it was delivered in a plastic bag and in cheap plastic containers. That was a definite disappointment and I would recommend against "room service" for this reason. The food was nothing to write home about either, especially for the amount of money we paid.
We will definetely be making a return trip to the Manor in the next year, but it will likely again be during the winter months as summer rates are a bit out of our price range.
- Reservation Options:
- TripAdvisor is proud to partner with Booking.com, Agoda and Priceline so you can book your Montauk Manor reservations with confidence. We help millions of travelers each month to find the perfect hotel for both vacation and business trips, always with the best discounts and special offers.
- Also Known As:
- Montauk Manor Hotel Montauk