I'm in Montauk almost every weekend of the summer and the Star Island Grill is where I eat a majority of my meals for either breakfast, lunch or dinner. Very laid back friendly atmosphere overlooking the Montauk Harbor and Inlet with beautiful sunset views. The food is simply amazing and highly recommended! In fact whenever my friends come for a re-visit, its the first stop on their wish list! I always try to have something new Chef Tony has cooking as a special but my usual favorites are his Lobster Roll or Sliders, the Grilled Fish Tacos and the BBQ Beef or Pork Sliders.