My wife and I stayed here for her birthday, and we will never stay here again. I’m shocked at how many good reviews there are for this place. For the rates they charge, on a weekday no less, what you get is a tiny motel room with a lack of upkeep. Our options were limited because we wanted a pet friendly spot (more on that later), but I expected a much better experience. We visited in the middle of a heat wave, and all you get in your room is a small wall A/C unit that doesn’t go below 72 degrees and sounds like a jet engine. The bathroom was in terrible condition, and the bed was 3 feet from the front door that had a huge gap on the bottom, so not only could you hear everything outside your room but the huge gap also allowed the heat to easily get in so the room never stayed cool during the day. The photos they provide on their website are very misleading. Feel free to compare them to the photos I took. I decided to pay extra for a Premium room instead of the Classic, thinking we’d get a nicer room and/or a view of the ocean. We got neither. The pictures on their website and other websites show an ocean view with a room that looks nothing like the room we got. The only difference between a Premium and Classic room is what level you’re on (the Premium rooms are on the second floor). My last gripe is with the pet policy. They charge you a $150 pet fee, but their policy is that you cannot leave your pet in the room alone. We’ve stayed at a number of pet friendly hotels and this is the first time we’ve come across this ridiculous policy. The fact that it was a pet friendly motel didn’t prevent some other guests from complaining to the front desk about our dog barking (a 7 lb Maltese). I would have loved to have had a conversation with whoever complained twice in one day about our dog barking. Both complaints were in the middle of the day. Why are you in your crappy room during a beautiful day? If you have a problem with dogs barking at a pet friendly hotel/motel, don’t stay at a pet friendly hotel. There’s plenty of other places to stay in Montauk that aren’t pet friendly. I highly recommend staying anywhere other than here.