I attempted to make a reservation for a birthday dinner for friends who were staying at the Montauk Yacht Club. I called SEVEN times, left 3 messages and was never called back. When the guests checked in, we relayed this to the front desk and received no apology whatsoever, and they made the reservation. Although the food was OK, the service at the restaurant was fair to poor. They were aware of the birthday in our party as the waiter wished a happy birthday when we ordered our drinks. Dessert was brought and the water asked if we wanted a candle...certainly not at that point once the dessert was on the table! It amazed us how identical drinks were ordered at the bar adjacent to the restaurant and in the restaurant, yet the restaurant charged us more. In a town with many choices to dine, this will NEVER be one of ours again.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.