My family and I have been to Mario too many times to count. The food is top notch and you you will not find better veal anywhere. My wife loves the fish selection which goes way beyond typical salmon and swordfish. We had St. Peters fish on one visit that took us back to the Amalfi coast. Wine selection is very good and good selections under $50. You don't see exactly what you want on the menu? Just ask they can probably make it. Service is second to none - try to get Michael as your waiter. He has been there for years and is fantastic. The vibe is traditional as is the crowd - dont expect a happening scene here. Prices are high for Hauppauge but cheaper than NYC. Mario is also old school, they will not bring the check until you ask for it, which is great if you want to linger and talk for a while. The final touch is the valet parking. The valet runs to fetch your car not strolls like he is doing you a favor. His tips reflect this. Overall one of the best restaurant experiences in the area. Enjoy!!!
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.