On a recent trip to Keuka Lake my wife and I stopped at the Blue Heron Cafe for lunch. We were told that the Blue Heron Cafe had a nice, lite lunch menu, as opposed to Bully Hill, which had a more "Full Lunch" menu. This was exactly what we were looking for, a lite lunch.
First off, what a view of the lake! Very nice!
The food - We both had the Apple Cider Chicken Soup and a Caesar Salad. Both were excellent, but the Apple Cider Chicken Soup was a real knock out surprise! WoW! I wasn't too sure about trying it, it sounded both very good and also like it could be a big mistake. I am so glad I took a leap of faith on this one - it was so good! Creamy, not too heavy though, you could taste the Apple Cider, not overpowering, just enough. The chunks of chicken were plentiful and tasty.
The Caesar Salad was quite good too, but alas, it did take a back seat to the Apple Cider Chicken Soup.
It was a bit windy and chilly outside that day, we sat at one of the two indoor tables. That was a good choice, I think if we had eaten outside our soup would have cooled off way too quickly, and so would we!
Suggestion - Add more indoor seating somewhere!
Add on if you have to.
I can see it being way too hot there in the middle of Summer.
I recommend that you stop and sample some wines and then enjoy a nice, lite lunch at the Blue Heron Cafe. And, if they have the Apple Cider Chicken Soup, you must try some!
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.