After reading all the positive reviews my husband and I were quite confident we would like it when we ordered a medium Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza. Getting a 10% discount through our stay at the Keuka Lakeside Inn certainly also helped with the decision making. Our problems started when we tried to eat the pizza back at the motel. The restaurant had supplied us with generous amounts of napkins and paper plates - but not with knives and forks!!!
The pizza smelled delicious and tasted delicious, but the middle was a total soggy mess. Sorry, but there is no better description! Most pizza places we are used to manage to balance the toppings on the dough, but not this one. In the end we were able to enjoy our meal by wrapping the soggy middle around the rest of the pizza - a less than elegant solution and an experience that I wouldn't want to repeat.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.