We're nearing the end of our second Colgate student's run and through the years the Hamilton Inn has been our favorite. The food is always good and consistent. Fish, red meat or any other meat -- it's always top notch and the preparations are not over-engineered. This time out we had prime rib (including end cut - YUM), scallops, and pork chops. The service and wine has also been good every time. They easily accommodate large parties (we always seem to be around 10 people). We've tried driving out to Cazenovia for the Brewster Inn, but the Hamilton Inn is just as good and right in Hamilton.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.