Honestly, I was really disappointed with Peter Luger's. We went there to celebrate my boyfriend's birthday. The service was fine. I do not have complaints about the service. The decor...sigh. This establishment is really, really, really dated. It honestly is quite drab and uninspiring. I just feel that the decor really detracted from the entire evening.
The food...it was average. I have been to many a steakhouse (e.g. Rare 650, Blackstone, Bones in Atlanta, Capital Grille, Ruth Chris, etc.). I was not impressed with the steak. It tasted fine. It was nothing to write home about. The tomatoes and onions as well as the bacon were delicious. The German style potatoes were also very good. The desserts were fine.
The overall experience was disappointing. I would not discourage anyone from trying Peter Luger. I would just level set expectations.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.