This place is like home. I always order a Greek salad with tuna salad on top. Or a Greek burger. It's friendly, comfortable, no-nonsense, and unpretentious. A godsend in the ridiculously pretentious scene that poor old East Hampton has become. That said, it's absurdly overpriced. My favorite Greek salad with tuna on top is something like $17 bucks. C'Mon! I still go to John Papas . . . I'll always go . . .but, you know, I could eat a much fancier and more delectable meal at, say, Cittanuova or even Yama Q for that. Anyway, John Papas is more or less the only place for miles where you can have a basic eggs/bacon/toast kind of breakfast. Bless them.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.