We have been renters and owners in the area for over 30 years, and Michael's has generally been one of our reliable go-to restaurants. It has had ownership and menu changes, but the atmosphere was always convivial, the food ranged from good to excellent (depending on the night and era), and we considered it an excellent value. This was our first visit in 2 summers, and even though the welcome was warm, the food nicely prepared, the usual crowd of locals was missing from the bar. Also missing was the early dinner special we used to love on Sundays, and no sign of a bargain lobster night. We left the restaurant full, and smiling, but not as broadly as we had before. Ownership? Management? Chef? I don't know, but at this time there are better food, values, and ambience to be had in the East Hampton/Montauk area.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.