We were in Taos last weekend for Labor Day weekend and we had to go back to Antonio's. We were there last year in April 2011 and we really enjoyed it then and we enjoyed it last weekend as well.
The person at the front desk at our motel recommended that we make reservations since it was a busy weekend. At first we made reservations for 2 at 7:30 and had to change it for 5 later one as we met new friends at our motel and ended up having dinner with them. They had never been to Antonio's before. We did not have any problems changing the reservations.
We would have liked to sit outside that night but they were extremely busy and all outside tables were occupied so the 5 of us sat inside. It was fine.
I had bragged about the guacamole made at your table to our friends and we all decided to order it but they couldn't do it that night. We were a bit disappointed. But our waitress told us that she would try to find us some guacamole and she did! That was great! The salsa was excellent also a bit spicy but to the liking of our friends from Texas.
I recommended the chile relleno en nogada to one of our new friends and he ordered it. It is the best chile relleno I have ever had! My husband and I also ordered it. All 3 of us really enjoyed our dish. It is by far my favorite and I will order it again when I return. I can't remember what the other two members of our group ordered but they said they enjoyed their dish.
We ordered beers, margaritas and sangrias.
The waitress was great and efficient considering how busy they were.
Overall I think our new friends liked the place and as for my husband and I we will return to Antonio's next time we are in Taos.