I have been eating at Tony's for as long as they have been open and I am NEVER disappointed. They make their pizza with a thin crust and it is the best pizza in Ocean County. My favorite is his Chicken Ceasar. The have a variety of specialty slices every day.
Dinner is always excellent. The meal is cooked fresh so you wait longer than most restaurants because it is always cooked to order. Entree prices average over 12.00. They give you their famous Rosemary Foccacia bread and it is worth having dinner there just for the bread.
We eat lunch there at least once a month. I recommend one of their focaccia Panini sandwiches.
I would recommend Tony's over other local italian restaurants. The atmosphere is very casual but don't let that discourage you from enjoying a quiet dinner. They are located in the Pathmark/Home Depot shopping center on route 9.