Would have to agree with the negative reviewers. The main key points that give this place a negative review is (1) the food is overpriced (2) for what you pay your food is just thrown on a plate without any decoration (3) most of the wait staff have no real clue on how to wait on a table plus cant speak english (4) a large majority of the customers that go into this place are loud trashy type as if the Randolph diner is the only place that accepts these types of people (5) some of the employees there especially the new ones obviously didn't pass any mental health tests.
As you look around the place, and this is supposed to be a new place, you'll see things scratched up and falling apart. You order an item say a hamburger, its just thrown on a plate with nothing else. Sometimes you get a plastic plate and some times you get a normal place, you'll see this plate with just a small hamburger on it and that's it. Anything above lettuce, tomato on a stale bun is an extra charge no fries nothing and your in the whole $10, without tax or drink. We wouldnt even dare eat anything other than pancakes and hamburgers because the kitchen cant cook the basics of basics. $19 for diner with nothing with it. Obviously the money gets pocketed by the owner and nothing into the place itself.
You cannot site down and have a relaxing time to yourself, its either you hear people cursing every other word behind you, or some person blasting their cell phone, not to mention the loud mouths in the bar area. Every time we go into the place, there's always an issue that goes unresolved. We've been reviewing places and this one every single time gets a negative review over the same things over and over again. Today got charged $5.00 for a small baked potato. There are waiters that will speak to you only when they are waiting on your table expecting to get a tip from you that's 5x what everyone else leaves them. The next day you walk right by them, they say nothing to you. Randolph Diner, Jefferson Diner, Hibernia Diner and Red Hut Diner, its all the same type of problems, the same type of trash. And the employees get fired they just rotate from the places above.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.