We've been going to Anthony's frequently over the past year and find it to be just great, being from Chicago and living in the NY area for over 25 years, pizza has to be really good for me to go back regularly. We typically order a large pizza and the house salad with mozzarella cheese. The pleasant surprise was to find real chunks of Italian sausage, not that sliced stuff you usually find on NY pizza. The wings with carmalized onions are wonderful, be sure to ask for blue cheese with them.
So why not a perfect score? The seating is too crowded. It's often so noisy we can hardly hear each other to visit. We never stay for dessert, primarily for this reason.
Service is always great!