We had spoken of going here often with friends, a few of whom had already been and raved. We liked the idea of ordering first and getting drinks downstairs. when the food arrived i thought, OK, iceberg lettuce, not my first choice in salad, but I dealt with it. Service was fine-Efficient, polite, nothing extraordinary. I was excited to finally dig in to one of their legendary steaks...after my first bite, I looked around to my friends and stated "Is it me? or is this tough and not very tasty?" We all concurred. even the friends that had been before claimed it wasn't as they recalled. I've had better steaks from Shop-Rite prepared by my husband. Very ordinary meal for a big price. Maybe it's the mystic of a "hidden gem" and the Mendham-ites claiming their little secret. Crossed off the bucket list.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.