New Yorkers have a code: If you leave the city, the bagel-making capitol of the world, don't bother eating bagels. The exception to that rule is Wonder Bagel. These tender, chewy giants are baked right in front of you in the back and are a classic NY-style bagel. They're like a marriage between Essa's humongous hole-free rounds and H&H's smaller, denser bagels. In other words, they're perfect.
I also love that Wonder has tofu vegetable cream cheese, which goes great on any of their classic flavors. Coffee's great--even their decaf is delish!
Very small store; limited seating inside and outside, though not impossible. Lines on weekends move quickly. Service is super-fast and given with a smile. Locals swear by it, and transplanted New Yorkers miss home a little less.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.