Nice people, nice atmosphere, but menu is mediocre at best. A couple of good entries, but not a lot of consistency. For reasons unknown, no restaurant has ever been able to make a success of this location (this is the fourth since we've been coming to Forked River), despite the fact that Caffrey's Tavern across the street is busy every night. I don't expect Rella's to make it for the long run. Maybe "five" is the charm!
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.