My husband and I purposely visited both Peter Lugers and here within a two week time frame to compare the taste and decided Cliff's had it better. We tried the porter house for two at both places. Here at Cliff's they even give you a sizzling hot plate to eat on. It's just so flavorful and has just the right amount of crisp on the outside and the inside melts in your mouth. Plus it's about $20 less than the porter house at Peter Luger's. I used to love going to Peter Lugers at their Long Island location, but the Brooklyn one was somewhat disappointing. No white cloth covered tables and even though the restaurant wasn't small the tables were cramped together and I had to get up when the table sitting behind me were leaving. When you're paying over $100 for dinner for two you'd expect some fanciness.
Hands down this is the best steak house I ever tried. Wonderful creamed spinach (I almost licked the plate) and salads too. Can't wait to go back! People who doesn't normally like steaks say that they love Cliff's steak.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.