Stopped here for lunch while out on the bike, and it's a good thing we have saddlebags because we took half the meal home. Other reviewers were so right about the huge portions and the fact that Plumstead Grill offers quantity AND quality, at very reasonable prices. Cindy was our helpful and friendly server, and she did a great job of checking in and keeping our iced teas full. We had the turkey reuben with sweet potato fries and the turkey club with regular fries. On both sandwiches, the turkey was fresh roasted, tender and juicy--no deli meat here--and it was abundant. The sweet potato fries were the best we have ever had, and both those and the regular fries were crisp on the outside, tender inside, and completely greaseless. The dessert menu was pretty astonishing for a casual grill, and if we weren't so full, we would have indulged. We look forward to doing so next time, which will certainly be soon. Lunch, including tax but before tip, was $22.00 total. A real bargain.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.