I visited Cape May as a day trip recently. I had this store marked before I came. I love fresh peanut butter, and this place does not disappoint.
They have a ton of fresh samples out- not just peanut butter- but almond, sunflower, and cashew. I admit, I tried everything! The winner for me was the butterscotch peanut butter. There are some flies buzzing around, which I hate- but it is summer- perhaps a screen to cover the samples?
The store staff was very friendly and explained the difference between the natural and organic peanut butter. I was very involved with the peanut butters- so I hardly noticed the other wares- baked goods, drinks, and other assorted goodies. I wound up taking home 3 types of PB, and some gourmet dog treats- total 14.00 dollars, which is not that different than buying supermarket PB- and trust me, once you start eating the "real," stuff- you will not want the Jif or Peter Pan stuff any longer!
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.