Oyster Bay's been a favorite for over twenty years, and it's still same-family owned and operated. The waitstaff returns year after year and the food is just as consistent. You can count on a friendly greeting from Gerry at the front door, and husband Chris continually puts out great food from the kitchen. My favorite app is the unique Lobster & Crab Crostini, and the list goes on and on. The bar is newly expanded and the pub area is chic & inviting. Right in the center of town, visitors don't have far to go, and there's plenty of complimentary parking. If I'm in Cape May for six weeks a summer, I'll be at Oyster Bay just as many times.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.