When this place was Jimmy's, it was a hidden local gem. The ice cream and pizza were fabulous. There were approximately 4 tables inside, and when you could get one, the home made Italian dishes were excellent. The owners and staff were friendly and personable. You felt like one of the family when you went there.
Then, they closed down for remodeling, and Casamari was born. It seemed as though they gave control of the restaurant to the daughter. The service became terrible. The food wasnt bad, but it wasnt great anymore. And the local people that went to Jimmy's for years were now just "customers". It seemed like they were trying too hard to make it a trendy fancy Italian eatery, but it didnt work. We went there three or four times after the change over, but couldnt hack the terrible service and the bad attitudes of the staff. And the food wasnt great anymore either. So we stopped going.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.